Hawaii Big Island Rental Car Crisis: How to Navigate the Shortage This Holiday Season

Hawaii Big Island Rental Car Shortage: What Travelers Need to Know

Planning a trip to Hawaii’s Big Island during the holiday season? Be prepared for an unexpected roadblock: a severe shortage of rental cars and skyrocketing prices for the few that remain. This issue has sparked frustration among travelers and locals alike, especially as the busy Christmas period approaches. Here’s everything you need to know to navigate the rental car dilemma and still enjoy your vacation.

A recent post on Reddit’s Hawaii forum highlighted the severity of the issue. It shared that there were virtually no car rentals available for the Big Island during the peak holiday season. Even Turo rentals, a popular alternative, were listed at exorbitant prices—up to $2500 per week. Rental agencies at the island’s major airports, including the Ellison Onizuka Kona International Airport (KOA), have shown no availability, and online searches for rental cars yielded limited options at best.

While the Hawaii Tourism Authority confirmed that rental prices are indeed higher during high-demand periods, it disputed claims of no availability, stating that cars were available from major rental companies at both the Hilo and Kona airports. However, multiple travelers have shared their experiences of struggling to find rentals, with some claiming prices are so high that renting a car becomes almost unaffordable.

The Current Rental Car Situation on the Big Island

The rental car shortage on the Big Island is most evident during the Christmas holiday season. According to recent reports, travelers are finding it nearly impossible to book a car at both major airports on the island. Searches on car rental websites like Hertz, Enterprise, Sixt, and Avis have turned up empty or have offered prices far above typical rates. On Turo, the only remaining rental cars are priced at $274 per day or more, a significant markup compared to previous years.

This shortage comes as no surprise to travel experts, who have long recommended booking holiday rentals as early as possible to secure the best deals and availability. Turo representatives specifically caution travelers to book well in advance, as demand surges in popular destinations like Hawaii. With prices soaring and availability scarce, many visitors may face difficult decisions about how to get around during their stay.

Logistical Challenges with Car Rentals

In addition to the shortage of available cars, travelers face logistical challenges that make renting a car even more difficult. Kolby Akamu Moser, a Hawaii Island native and filmmaker, shared her experience of renting cars from Hilo International Airport (ITO). Hilo, located about 77 miles from Kona, presents a unique set of challenges for tourists. The long drive between the two locations can be time-consuming, and most rental companies do not allow cars to be dropped off in Kona, meaning travelers would have to return to Hilo for drop-off.

This creates even more frustration for travelers, particularly those with tight schedules or limited time on the island. For those flying into Kona, the lack of car rental options could result in a situation where they are forced to seek alternative transportation, such as rideshares or public transit.

Rideshares and Public Transportation Alternatives

With rental cars in short supply, many visitors are turning to rideshare services like Uber and Lyft to get around the island. However, this comes with its own set of challenges. As pointed out by Moser, rideshare services are often unreliable, particularly in remote areas like Hawai’i Volcanoes National Park. In these areas, where public transportation and rideshare options are limited, travelers may find themselves stranded or forced to rely on expensive alternatives.

For those who are planning to travel on a budget, it may be wise to familiarize themselves with Hele-On, the island’s public bus system, which can help travelers get around without the need for a rental car. While it’s not as convenient as having your own car, Hele-On can be a cost-effective solution for reaching key destinations on the island.

Resort Options and Limited Rentals

If you’re staying at a resort, you may have another option available: on-property car rentals. Some resorts offer rentals for guests who only need a car for a portion of their trip. This can be a great way to explore the island without committing to a full rental car for your entire stay. Many resorts also offer transportation services to local attractions, which can further reduce the need for a rental car.

Despite these challenges, there are still options for travelers who find themselves without a rental car. Those who plan to stay primarily in and around their resort area may find that they don’t need to rent a car at all. Many popular resorts are within walking distance of major attractions, and some offer shuttle services to popular sites.

Preparing for the Car Rental Shortage

With the holiday season fast approaching, it’s important to plan ahead. If you’re flying into Hawaii for the holidays, be sure to book your rental car as soon as possible to avoid disappointment. If you’re unable to secure a rental car, consider alternative transportation options like public transit, rideshares, or resort-based rentals. Additionally, it’s a good idea to make use of tours and excursions that provide transportation, as this can reduce your reliance on a car.

Don’t forget that everyone flying in around Christmas Day is facing the same issue. Many tourists will arrive without realizing that rental cars are in short supply, and they’ll be left scrambling for transportation options. To avoid stress and ensure a smoother trip, make sure to confirm your car rental plans early and explore all available alternatives.

Conclusion

The rental car shortage on the Big Island is a growing concern for travelers, especially with the holidays fast approaching. While rental car agencies and Turo rentals are limited and prices are sky-high, there are still ways to get around. By planning ahead, considering alternative transportation options like public transit and resort rentals, and staying flexible, travelers can still enjoy their time on this stunning island without the stress of car rental shortages.